How to develop critical thinking skills in students

The concept of critical thinking can seem vast and abstract. But one of the most meaningful ways you can start to tackle it is by rethinking the role of the teacher.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 23, 2023

Prisma is the world’s most engaging virtual school that combines a fun, real-world curriculum with powerful mentorship from experienced coaches and a supportive peer community

Gathering, analyzing, interpreting, synthesizing, judging — essential skills in the era of information. But with kids in U.S. middle school and high schools using the word “bored” to describe themselves more frequently than any other adjective, it’s hard to imagine how students’ critical thinking can flourish.

The concept of critical thinking can seem vast and abstract. But one of the most meaningful ways you can start to tackle it is by rethinking the role of the teacher.

Instead of a leader who aims to teach students by spelling out the next steps and evaluates whether they were accurately completed, think of them as a coach who helps learners chart their own course. Just a like a sports coach can’t step out on the field and take the shot for their player, a learning coach gives tools, asks Socratic-style questions, encouraging students to explore — while cheerleading and offering feedback in real time.

Recentering the learner-coach relationship is an excellent way to lay the foundations for the development of critical thinking skills: It shows the learner that everything they do, from the sources they choose to examine to the way they construct their argument to the way they approach a brand new challenge, is a choice that they make.

But it’s not a win-lose situation: Learners get comfortable with making mistakes, encountering obstacles, getting regular feedback and course correcting as needed.

With that mindset, they’re already practicing critical thinking. Then, when it comes time to roll up their sleeves, they’ll feel more comfortable engaging with materials, evaluating different viewpoints, and developing their own opinions.

Here’s how to help learners become critical thinkers.

Emphasize curiosity

One outcome of critical thinking is judgment: Do I believe this source? How do these sources relate to one another and to my lived experience? Am I convinced by this argument? How would I go about solving this problem? Are there possibilities I am overlooking?

But there are a lot of steps that come before we can get to a place of confidence.

It starts with embracing curiosity as a value — modeling it ourselves and instilling it in our students.

One of our Prisma Powers, “applied curiosity,” is central to the project-based learning approach we take. In each theme, when we send our learners on “missions,” they’re presented with a series of open-ended questions to help guide them.

But we also practice how to engage with these questions in a productive way, giving the learners a set of guardrails that help them adjust into the new approach until, ultimately, they feel the intellectual mastery to forge forward on their own.

One way we do this is in our Collaborative Problem Solving Workshops, explained by Head of Learning Innovation, Emily Veno, in this way:

“The purpose of Collaborative Problem Solving Workshops is to create collaborative experiences related to the theme where learners build their discussion and teamwork skills in context of an interesting and relevant problem or a set of problems. Sometimes, they do this in a simulation, like when they had to solve a mystery of stolen eggs from a Zoo in the ‘Unsolved Mysteries’ theme and each week they had to vote on a suspect to eliminate, or in the ‘World of Wonder’ theme where they had to figure out how to power a city using a combination of resources.”

Pick relevant subjects

Curiosity implies a level of student engagement; a closed mind will never be a curious one. The most direct path to engagement is when we make it clear why a student is learning something, and that why is rooted in a real-life, hands on connection, whether it’s to them personally, to their community or to their broader interests.

Keep this approach in mind, and suddenly the sky’s the limit with possible ways to teach critical thinking skills. For example:

  • Ask students to put their problem-solving skills in service of a challenge their community might face — for example, to develop a disaster-preparedness kit for their town, based on actual potential threats, as we did in our “Cities of the Future” theme.
  • Teach decision-making skills in the context of everyday life — for example, in our Life Skills class, students make a weekly meal plan that is nutritious and within the family’s grocery budget.
  • Ask students to describe a difficult situation they witnessed or experienced, and then workshop a solution. (This works best in a learning environment where trust has already been established.)
  • Have learners gather materials that represent different points of view on a local matter (whether to develop green space to build affordable housing, the pros and cons of a sugar tax, how to increase bike ridership), synthesize the results, and write a letter to the mayor expressing their constructive solution.

Notice that these topics don’t neatly into a traditional academic subject. That’s part of what makes them so compelling: they reflect the interdisciplinary nature of real-world situations. Leena Williams, Lead Coach and Curriculum Designer in our high school, explains:

“21st century problems aren’t solved in neat subject-area boxes; they will be solved by doing the messy and creative work of bringing together disparate knowledge and experiences, combining them with strong values and ethical thinking, and having the courage to go out on a limb. Our curriculum puts learners in those positions and lets them experiment and think outside the box in low-stakes ways, now while they are young, so that they can build those foundations to draw upon as they reach higher education and the workforce. In short, we present things as complex and open-ended because they are — we don't tidy them up for kids because we trust that kids can handle it.”

Make space for self-reflection

A lot of critical thinking focuses outward — analyzing and judging the work of others. But in order to do that in a productive way, learners need to be comfortable analyzing their own thought processes, biases included.

Meta-cognition — thinking about your thinking — is one of the higher order thinking skills we emphasize throughout all phases of a learning cycle. You can incorporate this in your own teaching by building in opportunities — formal and spontaneous — for students to reflect on their growth and development.

  • Celebrate when they learn something that causes them to change their mind.
  • Model self-reflection, by underscoring when you learn something new.
  • Ask them to find multiple solutions to the same problem, to see that there isn’t just one “right” answer.

James McManus, High School Coach & Curriculum Designer, suggests the value of challenging student preconceptions and debunking myths. One way he does this is by role-playing everyday scenarios suggested by the students — for example, how to get out of an awkward conversation — and then critiquing the possible solutions as a group. “When they critically re-examine their gut reaction to something,” McManus says, “they learn to re-train their brains.”

Cultivate relationships between peers

A healthy group dynamic is one of the most important ingredients for developing critical thinking skills. It’s one thing to encourage students to consider different perspectives held by anonymous strangers in distant publications; it’s another when you’re face-to-face with the person who disagrees with you.

Our coaches help students navigate these complex interpersonal relationships by normalizing the fact that we all have our unique viewpoints — but at the same time, the cohort feels comfortable challenging one another because they know that’s part of the process.

When we engage in creative problem solving together, each learner is invested in helping their fellow Prismarians find the best approach for them — and to respect that someone else’s solution will likely be vastly different than their own. At Prisma, we don’t teach kids what to think, we teach them how to think. In that sense, regardless of what specific opinion each learner holds, the community strengthens because everyone is working towards the same objective: to develop these important skills.

98% of parents are confident that Prisma is preparing their child for their adult life.

Want to learn more about how Prisma can empower your child to thrive?

Talk with usTalk with us

More from our blog

Design Thinking for Kids

How kids can design projects that solve real-world problems

Emily Veno
• 
May 26, 2023

Best Homeschool Math Curriculum

The Homeschool Math Struggle

Emily Veno
• 
May 19, 2023

Best Homeschool Science Curriculum for Middle School

Falling in Love with Science

Emily Veno
• 
May 18, 2023

How to Make Friends When Homeschooled

There are plenty of ways that homeschoolers make friends and engage with their peers, while still reaping the benefits of a homeschool education.

Emily Veno
• 
May 12, 2023

Growth Mindset Questions for Kids

Tools to build self-awareness and resilience

Emily Veno
• 
May 9, 2023

AI in the Classroom

Best practices for this new technology

Emily Veno
• 
May 5, 2023

Interdisciplinary learning

The real world isn’t divided into school subjects. Learn how we design our interdisciplinary curriculum.

Emily Veno
• 
May 3, 2023

Online school burnout

Why it happens and how to avoid it

Emily Veno
• 
April 27, 2023

How to Explain the Importance of Education to a Child

Explore the importance of education for children’s overall development and get practical tips for convincing your kids of its importance.

Emily Veno
• 
April 25, 2023

Curiosity in Learning

The Superpower that Turns Kids into Lifelong Learners

Emily Veno
• 
April 20, 2023

Real world education

What would it look like if school prepared us for life?

Emily Veno
• 
April 18, 2023

Does it Matter if Your Child is Over-Scheduled?

Why is it that in a world of unprecedented technological advances and time-saving innovations, we seem to be busier than ever before?

Emily Veno
• 
April 13, 2023

Imagination for kids

Imaginative play isn’t just for preschoolers. Here’s how to spark your child’s imagination.

Emily Veno
• 
April 11, 2023

How to craft a homeschool cooking curriculum

Engaging kids in the kitchen goes beyond food preparation. Here’s how to incorporate cooking into your weekly lesson plans.

Prisma Staff
• 
April 6, 2023

Helping your child choose a career path

The job landscape is shifting before our eyes. Here’s how to help kids navigate future career choices.

Prisma Staff
• 
April 4, 2023

“Is high school fun?”

If your child has doubts, here’s how to help them get to a “yes.”

Prisma Staff
• 
March 30, 2023

7 tips to deal with high school burnout

With adolescent mental health in crisis, here’s how to support your high school student’s well-being.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 28, 2023

Why is Creativity Important in Education?

At its core, creativity is the expression of our most essential human qualities: our curiosity, our inventiveness, and our desire to explore the unknown.

Emily Veno
• 
March 24, 2023

Worldschooling: Our Complete Guide to Getting Started

Imagine your child exploring new countries, meeting people from different cultures, and gaining a deep understanding of the world in a way that simply isn't possible in traditional education.

Emily Veno
• 
March 22, 2023

Writing prompts for middle school students

Unstick your child’s creativity, stretch their thinking, and improve their writing skills with topics that tap into their passions.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 21, 2023

Cora & Caitlin's Prisma story

I never expected to find a family within my child’s school, but the leadership, teachers, parents and kids have become friends for life

Caitlin, Cora's mom
• 
March 21, 2023

Homeschool Burnout: How to Take Care of Yourself in Your Journey

Homeschooling can be overwhelming for parents. Here's how to recognize the signs of burnout & concrete solutions.

Emily Veno
• 
March 20, 2023

Why is school so boring?

What’s behind your child’s complaint — and what to do about it.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 17, 2023

What to do when your child has no friends

If building social skills has been a bumpy road for your kid, here’s how to help them form healthy friendships.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 14, 2023

How to make homeschool fun

The homeschool day can be quite efficient, compared to a typical public school day. Then, their school work completed, kids have plenty of time for extracurriculars, hobbies, unstructured play and generally... fun.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 9, 2023

My child hates school. Should I homeschool?

Possibly. But here’s what to do first.

Prisma Staff
• 
March 7, 2023

Teaching nutrition to high school students

To instill life-long healthy eating habits, take a hands-on approach

Prisma Staff
• 
March 2, 2023

The secrets of building a sense of community in online learning

Distance learning doesn’t have to be a drag. Here’s how Prisma creates a community-centered online learning environment.

Prisma Staff
• 
February 28, 2023

How does online high school work?

Distance learning is gaining popularity. Here’s what you need to know about online learning for high school students.

Prisma Staff
• 
February 23, 2023

How to build strong study habits for middle school

A bridge into high school, middle school is the time to prepare for independent learning. Here’s how to set the stage.

Prisma Staff
• 
February 21, 2023

How to help an easily distracted child

ADHD is only one reason for a short attention span. Find the cause, then try these tips for helping your child focus.

Prisma Staff
• 
February 16, 2023

How to help your child find their passion

There’s no roadmap to develop a true passion — but here are ways to make the journey more fruitful.

Prisma Staff
• 
February 14, 2023

Meet Kristen Shroff

Kristen Shroff is an experienced educational leader who has been with Prisma from the very beginning, first as a Founding Curriculum Designer & then as Head of School. Now, as CEO, she will lead Prisma into its next stage of growth.

• 
February 10, 2023

Meet Claire Cummings

Meet Claire Cummings, our Head of Middle School. Claire started out as a beloved Learning Coach in our middle school program before transitioning to the Head of School role in January 2023! She is based in Detroit, Michigan.

• 
February 10, 2023

How to teach life skills for teens

From making a meal to balancing a budget, here’s how to help teens learn to thrive in the real world.

Prisma Staff
• 
February 9, 2023

Meet Emily Veno

In our Meet the Team blog series, you’ll get to read more about the innovative thinkers behind Prisma. Next up is Emily Veno, one of Prisma's Founding Curriculum Designers. After two years focused on building Prisma's middle school curriculum, in her new role as Head of Learning Innovation she works across both the middle & high school programs.

• 
February 8, 2023

Meet Leena Williams

In our Meet the Team blog series, you’ll get to read more about the innovative thinkers behind Prisma. Next up is Leena Williams, the Lead Coach & Curriculum Designer in our new high school program.

• 
February 8, 2023

Motivating students who don't care

Get to the bottom of your child’s apathy and help them find their ‘why.’

Prisma Staff
• 
February 7, 2023

Major & Latasha's Prisma Story

At Prisma, we believe the families and learners who like to call themselves Prismarians—are our ‘secret sauce’! Here we highlight one of our favorite stories from the Prisma community

Latasha, Major's mom
• 
February 6, 2023

How to incorporate educational family trips into homeschooling

From national parks to beach vacations, design an in-the-field learning experience the whole family will enjoy

Prisma Staff
• 
February 2, 2023

How to switch to online school

Online learning takes many forms. Decide why you want to go remote — and the rest will fall into place.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 31, 2023

What are the benefits of homeschooling with ADHD?

Here’s how parents of ADHD children can set themselves up for successful learning at home.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 26, 2023

How to stay focused during online school

Online learning doesn’t have to be distracting. These tips can prime your child to thrive at home.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 24, 2023

Learning activities for gifted children

From early childhood through high school, homeschooling provides the ideal setting to facilitate a gifted child’s learning. Here’s how.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 20, 2023

What challenges do students with learning disabilities face?

And how can you support them in the classroom?

Prisma Staff
• 
January 17, 2023

What are the benefits of child-led learning?

From fostering a love of learning to developing problem-solving skills, child-initiated learning is a pillar of a successful homeschooling journey. Here’s how to get started.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 12, 2023

How to get your child interested in math

Focus on number sense and you’ll help your child add math skills to their toolkit.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 10, 2023

How to keep kids healthy & active during remote learning

Combine fun with a pinch of self-discipline, and you’ll be well on your way to a wellness routine your child wants to follow.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 5, 2023

How to get your child to open up

Kids need to develop their own world as they mature. But the stereotype of the zip-lipped pre-teen doesn’t have to be your reality.

Prisma Staff
• 
January 3, 2023

How to homeschool and work from home

It’s not easy to juggle full-time work and homeschooling — but it is possible. Here’s what we’ve learned about how to thrive.

• 
December 29, 2022

What language should my child learn?

Learning languages opens doors, offers connections and inspires new ways of thinking. Here’s some advice about which one(s) to pick.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 27, 2022

How to teach your child to be a critical thinker

Critical thinking matters for academics, work and relationships. Here’s how to lay the foundations at home.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 22, 2022

Life of a Prisma learner: Aaron

Read about the hands-on learning opportunities one Prisma high schooler tackled in the Secrets of the Biosphere theme

Emily Veno
• 
December 22, 2022

How to help your kids be more creative

Creative thinking is the key to problem-solving. Here’s how to foster creativity at home.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 20, 2022

Considering alternatives to college?

Traditional four-year college is only one option. Here’s how to inform your decision.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 15, 2022

What does Montessori homeschooling look like?

The Montessori approach focuses on early childhood. Here’s how the popular pedagogical method can lend itself to home-based learning for all ages.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 13, 2022

Is Roblox educational?

Here’s what parents need to know about the popular social media network.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 9, 2022

Don’t develop healthy habits for kids — do it with them.

Here’s what every parent should know about facilitating a routine that works for the whole family.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 5, 2022

‘Learning styles’ are a myth (part 3) — What is a kinesthetic learner?

Hands-on learning benefits all students. Here’s how to incorporate it into your homeschooling.

Prisma Staff
• 
December 1, 2022

‘Learning styles’ are a myth (part 2) — characteristics of an auditory learner.

There’s no evidence to confirm the validity of these popular labels. But here’s how auditory learning strategies can benefit everyone.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 29, 2022

‘Learning styles’ are a myth (part 1) — characteristics of a visual learner.

Although no studies link these popular labels to academic achievement, here’s how visual learning helps everyone.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 24, 2022

Is Discord safe for kids?

Here’s what parents need to know about the free, popular chat app.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 22, 2022

Reading is the Gateway to Learning: Here’s how to get your child interested in reading.

Incorporate these reading tips into your routine, and you’ll be on your way to fostering a love of reading in your child.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 18, 2022

Holiday, winter and Christmas art projects for kids

Ready to Deck the Halls? Here are projects to engage kids of all ages—and tackle your seasonal shopping with DIY keepsakes.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 16, 2022

What is the Socratic Method for Kids?

More than just asking questions in the classroom, the Socratic Method helps learners test their own ideas in a real-life context.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 10, 2022

What is the best homeschool curriculum?

Here are some guidelines to help sift through the infinite options.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 8, 2022

What is self-directed learning — and what are the benefits?

When students set the conditions of their learning experience, they show more creativity, passion and sticktuitiveness.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 3, 2022

How is Minecraft Educational?

With built-in lesson plans, educational tools, and endless problem-solving opportunities, Minecraft: Education Edition can help motivate kids in coding, science, language arts, and more.

Prisma Staff
• 
November 1, 2022

Stuffed with stuffing? Step away from the casserole and try these Thanksgiving art projects for kids of all ages.

Get into the spirit of gratitude with these easy Thanksgiving crafts for kids.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 27, 2022

Gratitude is one of the prime ingredients of happiness. Here’s how to teach kids to be grateful.

Teach children gratitude and they’ll experience better mental health, well being and social connection.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 25, 2022

Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder can make reading comprehension a struggle. Here’s how to help a child with ADHD learn to read.

8 tips to ensure learning disabilities don’t get in the way of building reading skills.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 20, 2022

Bored Students Don’t Thrive. Here’s How to Get Your Child Interested in School.

Why does your child dread Mondays? Once you know, take these steps to help them (re)discover their spark.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 18, 2022

Here’s how to prevent bullying in school - and what to do if it happens.

To stop bullying behavior, educate yourselves and your children.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 13, 2022

Why do kids get bullied at school — and why do kids bully others?

Bullying is about a power dynamic between peers. To interrupt it, first understand why it happens.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 11, 2022

How to build confidence in kids

Children’s Mental Health is in Crisis. Here’s How to Help Develop Your Child’s Self-Esteem.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 6, 2022

What is twice exceptional - and how can homeschooling help?

To reach their high potential, twice-exceptional children benefit from a flexible learning environment.

Prisma Staff
• 
October 4, 2022

Halloween art projects for kids

The holiday season is the time to get your hands dirty with these Halloween craft ideas - candy corn optional.

Prisma Staff
• 
September 29, 2022

How to help a child with dyslexia at home

Dyslexic kids often lose their love of learning. Here’s how parents can help them rediscover it.

Prisma Staff
• 
September 27, 2022

How to support your LGBTQ child

The challenges of adolescence can be magnified for LGBTQ kids. Here’s how to help them thrive.

Prisma Staff
• 
September 22, 2022

What challenges do LGBTQ students face?

From bullying to finding a safe bathroom, LGBTQ students navigate a tough landscape at school.

Prisma Staff
• 
September 20, 2022

How to Make Learning Fun

What we know about the relationship between ‘hard fun’ and learning. (Hint: It’s not about playing games in between worksheets.)

Prisma Staff
• 
September 15, 2022

Want to raise successful kids?

Here’s what we mean by ‘success’ at Prisma - and how we use it to help kids thrive.

Prisma Staff
• 
September 13, 2022

Homeschooling Socialization Guide

What parents need to know about socialization in—and out of—the classroom to help your homeschooler thrive.

Prisma Staff
• 
August 16, 2022

How to start your own business as a kid

Child entrepreneurship is trending. Here are three steps to developing an innovative business that stands out from the crowd.

Prisma staff
• 
August 4, 2022

What is project based learning?

A hands-on approach to develop real-world skills, resiliency and a love of learning — here’s how we practice it at Prisma.

Prisma Staff
• 
August 2, 2022

Writer + Programmer = Calliope Ghostwriting

A Shared Name and Diverse Strengths Led Two Bens to Build an AI Writing Business.

Prisma staff
• 
July 7, 2022

Alternatives to School

When traditional public school isn’t the best option, consider these alternatives.

Prisma Staff
• 
July 1, 2022

How to Develop a Growth Mindset for Kids

Five ways parents can help their kids see themselves as a work in progress.

• 
June 22, 2022

Top 7 tips for how to recover from gifted kid burnout

Gifted kids face unique challenges when it comes to burnout. Here’s how parents can help.

Prisma staff
• 
June 21, 2022

What is worldschooling?

For travel-hungry families dreaming of school vacation, there’s much to celebrate about shifts in the way we live, work and educate our children.

Prisma staff
• 
June 16, 2022

How to start homeschooling

To create a customized education for your child takes more than a checklist. This three-stage framework can help you get started.

• 
June 14, 2022

Pros and cons of homeschooling

If you’re homeschool-curious, here’s what 100 families have to say about the biggest advantages and disadvantages of homeschooling.

Prisma staff
• 
June 10, 2022

How does Homeschooling Work in the Modern Era?

With homeschooling, the sky’s the limit – and there’s a lot on your plate. Learn about how to make this growing trend work for your family.

Prisma Staff
• 
June 9, 2022

Building healthy screen time habits: What Prisma kids say

Learning how to use the internet safely, smartly, and creatively is one of the most essential skills for success in our hyper-connected world. Prisma learners just wrapped up their Cyber Citizens learning

• 
April 2, 2021

Introducing Prisma LIVE

A live learning platform purpose-built for kids. It's a new, fun and engaging way for kids to learn and collaborate together virtually.

• 
March 19, 2021

Connected learning for a connected age

Technology has completely revolutionized how we shop, communicate, entertain ourselves, and even how we work, but no such revolution has happened in education.

• 
March 5, 2021

Prisma: a first retrospective

We’ve officially wrapped up our first ever fall session at Prisma and are excited to share our learnings and observations with you.

Victoria Ransom
• 
December 17, 2020

Join Prisma from anywhere in the USA this fall

Starting today, families can apply to join Prisma from anywhere in the USA. Here’s how it will work. You can still apply to any of our five founding cohort hubs (Chicago, Los Angeles, Salt Lake City, San Francisco, or Tampa) if you live nearby.

• 
July 27, 2020

A Stress-free switch to learning from home this fall

Over the past week, as millions of parents have realized that traditional in-person schooling may not be safe or available come September, a new twist on an old phenomenon has emerged.

• 
July 22, 2020

Be a founding family!

We're excited to announce the rollout of Prisma cohorts in 5 US cities: San Francisco, Los Angeles, Chicago, Tampa and Salt Lake City.

• 
July 17, 2020